Skip to main content
Free gold and coin appraisals by appointment in Barrio Logan and across San Diego County (619) 567-1014
San Diego Gold and CoinCoins · Gold · Silver
Menu

Selling old U.S. coins in San Diego

Albums, blue folders, proof sets, rolls and coffee cans. We go coin by coin, pull out anything scarce and tell you plainly which coins are common.

Coin album with a magnifier

Collections from all over

San Diego has drawn retirees from every state for decades, and their coin collections came with them. Many albums here were started in Ohio, Illinois or New York and finished in Clairemont or Escondido.

Navy families also have a habit of collecting. Sailors on long deployments sometimes filled folders with change from home, and those albums still turn up in Coronado and Point Loma estates.

Dates worth a closer look

Most old coins are common. These get a careful check.

  • 1909-S VDB, 1914-D and 1931-S wheat cents
  • 1937-D three-legged buffalo nickel
  • 1916-D Mercury dime
  • 1916 and 1918/7-S Standing Liberty quarters
  • 1932-D and 1932-S Washington quarters
  • 1893-S and Carson City Morgan dollars

San Francisco mint coins

Coins with an S mint mark were struck in San Francisco and often circulated heavily in California. Several of the scarcest 20th century dates are S mint coins, which is why West Coast collections deserve a close look. Skip the sorting, because every coin gets checked at the table anyway.

Ocean air and old coins

Salt air near the coast speeds up toning and corrosion. Copper turns dark or green, and silver picks up spots. Please do not clean any of it. Move coins out of garages and storage units into the house and bring them as they are.

Proof and mint sets

Sets from 1964 and earlier hold 90 percent silver. The 1965 to 1967 special mint sets include a 40 percent half. Most clad proof sets from 1968 to the 1990s sell near face, and the silver proof sets sold from 1992 on carry silver. San Francisco struck almost all U.S. proof coins after 1968, so every one of those coins carries an S.

Commemorative half dollars

Early commemorative halves struck from 1892 to 1954 are all 90 percent silver and sell well above melt. San Diego's own 1935-S and 1936-D halves turn up in local collections, along with the Oregon Trail, Texas, Booker T. Washington and Columbian Exposition halves. We price each one on its date and condition.

Errors and oddities

Doubled dies, off-center strikes, missing clad layers and wrong planchets interest collectors. Nine times out of ten, a coin that looks like an error was knocked around after it left the mint. Under the loupe we can usually tell you which kind you have within a minute.

Coins we buy

  • Indian Head and wheat cents
  • Buffalo and Jefferson war nickels
  • Mercury and Roosevelt silver dimes
  • Standing Liberty and Washington silver quarters
  • Walking Liberty, Franklin and Kennedy halves
  • Morgan and Peace dollars
  • Proof and mint sets

How old coins are priced

U.S. silver coins from 1964 and earlier always carry their silver value. Copper and nickel coins start at face. Date, mint and grade decide how much higher a coin goes.

Better coins are listed one by one with grade and price. Common coins are grouped by type with a count.

Further reading: Standing Liberty quarter values

Get a free written offer

We call back the same day to set a time. Se habla español.

Or call (619) 567-1014

Also buying

Common questions

Are my coins worth anything?
Silver coins always are. Many copper and nickel coins are worth face or a little more. We tell you which is which.
Should I clean old coins?
No. Cleaning lowers value.
Do you buy incomplete albums?
Yes. Leave the coins in place and we look at each one there.